Eighteen-year follow up after Hancock II bioprosthesis insertion
Legarra J.J., Llorens R., Catalán M., Segura I., Trenor A.M., de Buruaga J.S., Rábago G., Sarralde A.
Division of Cardiovascular Surgery, University Clinic, University of Navarra, Pamplona, Spain.
BACKGROUND AND AIM OF THE STUDY
The long-term (18 years) results after aortic (AVR), mitral (MVR) and double (aortic/mitral, DVR) valve replacement with Hancock II bioprosthesis were investigated.
Between 1978 and 1996, 279 Hancock II bioprostheses were implanted in 269 patients (166 males, 113 females; mean age 61.8+/-13.3 years). There were 135 AVR (48.4%), 122 MVR (43.8%) and 22 DVR (7.8%). Preoperatively, 208 patients (77.3%) were in NYHA functional class III/IV, 53 (19.7%) had previous cardiac surgery, and 19 (7.1%) underwent concomitant coronary artery bypass. Follow up (mean seven years) was 96% complete, with a total of 1,857 patient-years.
There were 20 early (7.3%), and 78 (29.0%) late deaths. At the last follow up, 68.3% of patients were in NYHA functional class I/II. The actuarial survival rate of patients at 10 and 18 years after discharge was 67.7+/-5.0% and 44.7+/-8.8% after AVR and 64.5+/-5.6% and 32.7+/-11.5% after MVR, respectively; survival after DVR was 74.0+/-11.2% at 12 years. At 10 and 18 years, actuarial freedom from thromboembolism was 83.5+/-4.5% and 73.1+/-10.5% after AVR and 82.1+/-4.3% and 73.2+/-7.3% after MVR; it was 78.4+/-15.0% after DVR at 12 years. At these times, actuarial freedom from hemorrhage was 88.7+/-3.8% and 83.5+/-6.2% after AVR and 79.0+/-4.9% and 32.6+/-23.3% after MVR; freedom after DVR was 36.2+/-26.6%. Probability of freedom from endocarditis at 10 and >15 years was 93.4+/-3.5% and 85.9+/-7.8% after AVR and 97.0+/-2.1% and 97.0+/-2.1% for MVR, respectively; freedom at 10 years after DVR was 75.0+/-21.6%. Freedom from structural deterioration at 10 and 18 years was 77.9+/-5.3% and 18.7+/-14.6% after AVR and 78.3+/-6.0% and 32.1+/-10.2% after MVR; freedom at 10 and 12 years after DVR was 64.0+/-17.5% and 32.0+/-24.2%. A low incidence of structural valve deterioration was found in AVR patients aged >65 years (p = 0.0478). Hemorrhage and paravalvular leak were more frequent in MVR (p = 0.0296 and 0.0309, respectively). No difference was seen in thromboembolism after anticoagulation for one or three months after AVR. Actuarial freedom from explantation at 10 and 18 years was 73.1+/-5.9% and 15.9+/-13.5% after AVR and 77.1+/-6.1% and 37.3+/-9.7% after MVR; freedom at 10 and 12 years after DVR was 72.0+/-17.8% and 24.0+/-20.4%.
Over an 18-year follow up, the Hancock II bioprosthesis has shown satisfactory results, with a low incidence of valve-related complications, especially in elderly patients in the aortic position.
CITA DEL ARTÍCULO J Heart Valve Dis. 1999 Jan;8(1):16-24